On this page
You are choosing between the size that closes around that deep chest and the size that actually covers the back to the tail, and for a Greyhound, Doberman, or Vizsla you rarely get both from the size chart alone.
I think first of a three-year-old Greyhound I helped fit last November, all legs and keel, shivering after school pickup in a light rain. His owner had bought a large based on weight, and the back panel ended three inches short of his tail while the chest strap floated. We re-taped him on the kitchen floor: 68 pounds on the scale, 32 inches around the deepest part of the chest, 28 inches from withers to tail base. Once we matched those two numbers instead of the weight chart, the next coat sat flat over his spine and closed with two fingers of room at the sternum.
That is the decision to make concrete before you shop. A deep chest needs wrap without strangling the elbows, and a long back needs coverage without sailing like a sail. Weight tells you almost nothing here.
Measure the dog you have, not the size on the tag
Stand your dog square on a non-slip floor after a walk, when breathing is calm. Tape chest at the deepest point just behind the elbows, tape back length from prominent withers to tail base, and tape neck loosely where a collar sits. Write all three down and shop chest first, length second, neck last.
A common question is whether to size up for chest room. Resist that impulse until you check length, because most waterproof shells scale wider and longer together and deep-chested breeds break that ratio. Guidance from the American Veterinary Medical Association reminds owners that cold, wet exposure matters most along the core and extremities, which is why a coat that gapes at the chest or rides short over the kidneys fails at its main job. Breed background from the American Kennel Club helps explain why sighthounds and working breeds carry that tucked, keeled shape that off-the-rack coats rarely anticipate.
If you use a harness under a coat, fit them together. See Choosing a Harness for a Deep-Chested Breed for why a Y-front that clears the sternum prevents the coat from shifting.
Chest first, length second, neck last.
Why chest-first sizing fails when you stop there
The tradeoff showed up with a middle-aged Doberman whose owner sized up to clear his chest, then cinched everything tight to stop the back from sailing. For five rainy evening walks it looked workable, until the extra fabric bunched behind the elbows and rubbed two thumb-sized bald spots into the armpit hair. He started shortening his stride and pausing at curbs, the way sports-medicine dogs do when range of motion feels blocked. We dropped back down a size, let the chest panel sit at its limit with a Y-shaped harness underneath, and added a belly flap instead of more width. The lesson held: extra room without structure may help support comfort on paper while creating drag in motion.
I score this the way I score all gear, on fit, durability, comfort, and value, and waterproof coats win or lose on comfort in motion. Look for a deep cut or darted chest, an adjustable sternum strap plus a second belly strap, elastic or articulated leg cutouts that do not press the elbow, and a back vent or split tail flap so the dog can trot and toilet. Seam tape and a DWR finish may help support water resistance, but they cannot compensate for a chest that pulls or a hem that lifts.

The five-minute fitting sequence that prevents rubs
Slip the coat on without fastening and settle the withers seam right on the bony ridge. Close the chest strap to two fingers of room, then the belly strap to the same, then check the neck for a flat hand of clearance. Watch from the side as your dog walks ten steps, turns both ways, sits, and sniffs the ground.
You want no more than an inch of lift at the tail in a trot, no folding behind the elbows, and no pressure crease across the shoulder. Run a finger under every strap after movement, check for damp fur wicking in at the chest gap, and confirm the tail opening clears waste. If you are debating insulation level, Sweater vs Coat: Which Does Your Dog Need lays out when waterproofing earns its keep versus a knit layer.
My evidence-bounded recommendation is this: buy for the smallest chest closure that still allows full stride, then solve remaining length with style, not size. A three-strap rain shell or a breed-cut coat with an extended back panel will do more for a deep-chested dog than sizing up in a boxy cut. A sceptical friend will ask if this is fussy marketing, and the honest answer is that a coat cannot change diet, conditioning, or recovery, it can only preserve warmth and dryness while the dog moves freely, which is worth paying for only if motion stays clean.
When to break your own fitting rules
Sometimes the standard order has to bend, like it did for a nine-year-old Vizsla with a sway back and early hind-end stiffness I saw on a blustery reservoir trail. His measured length fell between sizes, and the textbook pick left his lower back exposed whenever he dropped his head to sniff. We broke the rule and chose the longer shell even though the chest needed taking in almost to the last Velcro tooth, then balanced it with a fleece snood at the neck and a shorter 1.5-mile loop to test movement before committing. On that loop his topline stayed dry to the tail and he trotted out without the hunched pause he showed in the short coat.
Older dogs, post-surgical dogs, and narrow puppies with huge growth ahead are the usual exceptions. Prioritize coverage and easy on-off over a perfect tailored line, add a light base layer rather than cranking straps, and recheck fit every two weeks through winter coat changes. If the chest closes without pulling and the back stays covered at a trot, what else does that coat need to prove?
Sources
- Cold-Weather Animal Safety — American Veterinary Medical Association
- Dog Owner Resources — American Kennel Club